Understanding Plan Enrollment

Many Workers Misunderstand Retirement Plan Enrollment

A recent study by Principal Financial Group found that 59% of nonparticipating employees mistakenly believed they were contributing to their workplace retirement plans. The study highlighted several reasons for this confusion:

  1. Enrollment Assumptions:
    • 49% thought they were automatically enrolled.
    • 41% assumed they had signed up themselves.
    • 77% believed they started saving as soon as they were eligible.
  2. Plan Design and Miscommunication:
    • According to TJ Arcuri from SageView Advisory Group, plan design issues and miscommunication often lead to these misconceptions. For instance, plans offering a 3% nonelective contribution can make participants think they are actively contributing when they are not.
  3. Eligibility Confusion:
    • The study found that 22% of respondents were unsure if they qualified for benefits, with a significant portion being from Generation Z. Employees who have held multiple jobs may be uncertain about plan features like auto-enrollment.

Addressing the Digital Divide

Chris Littlefield, president of Retirement and Income Solutions at Principal, noted that direct deposit has removed regular reminders of paycheck deductions, creating a blind spot for employees. To address this, Principal recommends:

  • Designating Enrollment Periods: Discussing enrollment during benefits election periods and performance reviews.
  • Increasing Communication: Using personalized communication to alert employees about their enrollment status and encouraging participation through various channels.

Power of Personalization

Personalized communication, such as including the plan name and specific enrollment details, can help noncontributing employees realize their status. Principal's report emphasizes the need for continuous communication and automated reminders to ensure employees complete the enrollment process.

Automated Features

Littlefield highlighted the benefits of automated features like auto-enrollment, which can significantly increase participation rates. Plans using auto-enrollment achieve 90% participation, compared to plans without this feature. The SECURE 2.0 provision requiring new plans to implement automated features is a step in the right direction, but existing plans must also adopt good design practices for better outcomes.